Nagato isn’t the right character for a spin-off

nagato yuki chanWhy is Nagato Yuki not the best character for a spin-off?

I’ve touched this subject a little bit in the comments and the seasonal posts, but I want to break it down a bit further why I’ve come to this conclusion.

In my experience with spin-offs, most notably Fate/Illya, we’ve seen that a cast member will get its own dedicated show. Tearing it out of the setting and creating a standalone show. Not all standalone shows perform as well, but can also deepen the story for a particular character that piqued the interest of the audience. A good cast completes each other and has a certain chemistry that is not achieved when shifting the focus.

Nagato Yuki-chan seems to be part of the lesser performing shows as Yuki is a very quiet character. With a quiet character the question arises how does this add up to an engaging show? Well, bluntly said, it doesn’t. With the focus shifted we see Yuki’s inner romantic trying to pursue her love interest, Kyon. The oblivious monologue character, who did an outstanding job in the KyoAni adaptations of Haruhi Suzumiya.

It’s a shame the studio explored a romantic side of Yuki. True there were hints she wanted to be noticed by Kyon in the Disappearance of Haruhi Suzumiya, but the chemistry between Haruhi and Kyon was far greater. The overwhelming energy of Haruhi pulled Kyon out of a comfort zone that is lacking in the interactions between Kyon and Yuki.

Of course I’m not against Yuki as a character, I’m confident she has quite the fan base, but purely from a production perspective the spin-off can’t live up to the vibe of the original adaptations. The scenes with Haruhi are still the most fun to watch and her shenanigans are unrivaled. Let me know in the comments who you’re rooting for in the Haruhi-franchise!


3 thoughts on “Nagato isn’t the right character for a spin-off

  1. infinitezenith says:

    I thoroughly enjoyed the manga spin-off: it represented a good change of pace from the original Suzumiya Haruhi light novels, which I found to be unremarkable. The reason Haruhi’s popularity reached the extent that it did was because of Kyoto Animation’s anime adaptation featured superb voice acting that captured the spirit of the characters, top-tier animation and catchy music that made Suzumiya Haruhi fun to watch. Then The Disappearance of Suzumiya Haruhi further raised the bar: this masterpiece of a movie truly illustrated the extent that Haruhi and Kyon care for one another.

    I’ve heard numerous mentions of Yuki’s lack of presence in The Disappearance of Nagato Yuki, and while a vast majority of viewers are treating it as a negative aspect (to the point of dropping the anime), there’s a reason for reducing Yuki’s role in this spin-off; it is this lack of presence, the “disappearance” mentioned in the title that seems to drive home the fact that the growing relationship between Yuki and Kyon is an enduring one. Despite every other character’s comparatively overwhelming presence, the sort of bond between the two persists. The reason for this is given in the manga’s seventh volume, and since that constitutes a spoiler, I won’t mentioned it at present.

    Ultimately, the relationship between Yuki and Kyon it does bring out a kinder side in Kyon: while seemingly detrimental to The Disappearance of Nagato Yuki, I contend that it evokes a greater sense of appreciation for Haruhi in the original series by further illustrating the sort of impact she has on him. The Disappearance of Nagato Yuki is not something for viewers who are quite unfamiliar with Suzumiya Haruhi, but instead, acts as a good comparison between the different outcomes of Kyon’s choices back in the movie. I rooted for Yuki in the movie, and I’m still rooting for Yuki here: in the original universe, she was the one who was dependable, solidly present as a source of help, and in this universe, she’s perhaps a more extreme representation of the sort of person that I’m (probably) compatible with.

    • ninetybeats says:

      Thanks for your eleborate reply. Indeed the series stays true to its title if you solely judge it in that context. Perhaps the reason a lot of people drop the show is because the show seems to position itself as a love story between Kyon and Nagato, while in essence she is more on the lay low and the narrative in this adaptation doesn’t really complement that fact.The clever mix between visuals, narrative and overall feel also don’t stand up to the KyoAni version, putting many people off, yet it was to be expected.

      • infinitezenith says:

        As far as the adaptation go, it’s satisfactory with respect to depicting the manga’s story. I think that KyoAni might’ve been able to do a better job with the visuals, but other than that, it’s unlikely that this spinoff would do as well as the original.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s